The following 2016 Creighton Prep Varsity players were selected on May 13, 2016, by Nebraska Premier Lacrosse, the 2016 Nebraska High School Lacrosse Association (NELAX) All Star Game sponsor, to participate in the 2016 NELAX All Star Game on May 26 (subsequently rescheduled to June 2 due to inclement weather): Carson Johnson (Junior Attack), Mitch Rhoades (Senior Midfielder), Dante Davoli (Senior Midfielder), Tobias Greene (Senior Defense), Edward Johnson (Senior Defense), Sam Johnson (Junior Goalie) and Leo Dunlap (Sophomore LSM).
Coach Haney stated: "I am extremely proud of the Creighton Prep players chosen for the 2016 NELAX All Star Game. Selection to the 2016 NELAX All Star Game is the highest individual honor a Nebraska high school lacrosse player can achieve. These seven players each represent the most talented, hardworking and skilled players the Creighton Prep Lacrosse Program has to offer. Our future players would do well to emulate the skill development, practice habits and sportsmanship of each of Creighton Prep's 2016 All Star selections."